What Are The Pros And Cons Of DIY Roof Repair?

We always receive questions related to whether or not it is recommended to attempt DIY roof repairs. 

The simple answer is that it completely depends on your situation. For very minor problems, you can attempt a DIY roof repair, but in most cases, it is best to leave the job to experienced professionals. 

At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, LLC, we are your local roofers in Pittsburgh, PA. In this article, we will help you make the right decision of whether to attempt DIY roof repair.

What Are the Pros of DIY Roof Repairs?

Yes, there are some pros of DIY roof repairs. Here, we will quickly take a look at the benefits of DIY roof repair.

#1 Cost Savings on Labor

By handling roof repairs yourself, you can save significantly on labor costs, which generally make up 40% to 50% of professional roofing repair expenses. 

You'll only need to pay for the materials and other important tools, and this can result in some savings for simple repairs like replacing a few shingles or patching minor leaks.

#2 Immediate Response to Problems

When you notice a roofing issue, you can address it immediately without waiting for any contractor's availability. 

This quick response can prevent minor problems from becoming major issues, especially during emergencies like small leaks during stormy weather. Having the ability to make immediate temporary repairs can save your home from water damage.

#3 Learning Valuable Home Maintenance Skills

Taking on DIY roof repairs helps you develop useful home maintenance skills and better understand your roof's condition.

This knowledge can help you identify potential problems early and make more informed decisions about future repairs or replacements. You'll also be better equipped to perform regular roof maintenance tasks.

What Are The Cons of DIY Roof Repair?

While DIY repairs can be tempting, there are several important drawbacks to consider:

#1 Safety Risks

Working on a roof without any experience and safety equipment can be extremely dangerous. Falls from roofs are among the most common home improvement accidents, and they can result in severe injuries or worse. Professional roofers are properly trained in safety procedures, and they have the right equipment and experience to work safely at heights. 

#2 Potential for Mistakes

Without any proper experience, there is a high chance that you will make mistakes that could worsen the existing problems or create new ones. Incorrect repairs can cause water damage, mold growth, and other structural issues that end up being much more expensive to fix than the original problem would have been with professional repair.

#3 Warranty Concerns

DIY repairs might void your roof's warranty. Many manufacturers' warranties require that repairs be performed by certified professionals. If you attempt repairs yourself, you could lose valuable warranty coverage that could have protected you from future expenses.

#4 Hidden Damage May Be Missed

Professional roofers are trained to spot underlying issues that might not be visible to your untrained eye. What appears to be a simple repair might actually be a symptom of a larger problem that requires more extensive work.

When You Can Consider DIY Roof Repair For Your Property

In some situations, you can consider doing DIY roof repairs to save time and money, but it’s important to understand the limitations of your skills. If you aren’t sure about any part of the repair process, call professionals for help. 

#1 Missing or Damaged Shingles

The first situation is doing a temporary repair for any missing or damaged shingle on your roof. If one or two shingles on your roofs are cracked and when that area of your roof is easily accessible, you can apply a roof sealant by yourself. 

Also, if you notice missing shingles, you can temporarily cover that area with a tarp by yourself until the professionals arrive to replace it. You can also consider a DIY shingle replacement for one or two shingles if you have the proper tools, safety equipment, and, most importantly, experience. 

#2 Minor Leaks

Small, easily accessible leaks that can be fixed with roofing cement or sealant might be suitable for DIY repair leak fixes. 

However, make sure you can accurately locate the source of the leak. Roof leak repair DIY projects often start with a thorough inspection of your attic during daylight hours.

#3 Emergency Situations

Sometimes, in emergencies like during severe weather, roof repairs become important. Keep materials in your home like roof sealers, tarps, and basic tools for temporary fixes until professional help arrives. 

When choosing the right sealant for your roof, you'll find various options, including rubber-based, silicone, acrylic, and urethane sealants, each designed for specific repair situations. Choose the appropriate type based on your specific repair needs and weather conditions.

#4 Clogged Gutters

If you are facing clogged gutters or drainage problems, you can likely perform DIY roof repairs. Cleaning gutters and making minor gutter repairs are generally safe DIY tasks that can help you prevent larger issues. 

Regular maintenance should include removing debris at least once every three months, ensuring proper water drainage throughout the system, securing any loose mounting brackets, and addressing any leaks that develop at the seams. 

This ongoing care helps prevent water damage and extends the life of both your gutters and roof.

When You Should Consider Hiring Professional Roof Repairs For Your Home?

In most situations, professional help is strongly recommended:

#1 Major Damage

If your roof has multiple problems or widespread damage, professional repairs are necessary to make sure all issues are properly addressed. When tackling major roof damage, you might do more harm than good. 

If you make the wrong repairs, it can result in more expensive repairs. So make sure to hire a professional to perform the right repairs for major damage

#2 Steep or Complex Roof Design

If your roof has a steep pitch or complex architectural features, professional expertise and equipment are essential for safe repairs. 

Roofing work is quite risky, especially in the case of pitched roofs, and as mentioned above can lead to injuries for inexperienced individuals. 

#3 Age-Related Issues

If your roof is nearing the end of its lifespan (generally 20 to 25 years for asphalt shingles), professional assessment is important to determine whether repair or replacement is more cost-effective.

Choose a reputed roofing contractor in your local area to locate and address all the repairs and help you make the right choice. 

#4 Insurance Claims

When storm damage or other covered events cause roof damage, professional repairs ensure proper documentation and work quality for insurance purposes. 

If you harm anything while attempting a DIY roof repair, it can void your insurance coverage. For this reason, it is better to hire professional roof repair services if you are not confident doing the job. 

#5 Structural Concerns

Any issues involving the roof's structure, including sagging areas or damaged support components, require professional attention.

These are concerning situations that you should never address through DIY roof repairs. You not only risk your roof’s health but also your own safety when you perform DIY roof repairs for this kind of damage. 

How Much Does It Cost To Repair A Roof? Comparing DIY Vs. Professional Roof Repair Cost

The cost of roof repairs obviously varies different depending on whether you choose DIY or professional services.

For DIY repairs, you can expect to spend between $100 to $500 for minor fixes. This typically includes basic materials like shingles costing $3 to $5 per square foot, roofing cement at $10 to $20 per tube, basic tools ranging from $50 to $150, and safety equipment around $100 to $200.

If you opt for professional services in the Pittsburgh area, the costs are naturally higher but include expert labor and guaranteed work. 

Minor professional repairs generally range from $300 to $800, moderate repairs can cost between $800 to $2,500, and major repairs might run $2,500 to $5,000 or more. 

Schedule Professional Roof Repairs In Pennsylvania

At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, LLC, we are your trusted roofing company in Pittsburgh, PA. If you are looking for high-quality roof repairs in Pennsylvania, our team has the right experience to handle all your roofing needs, not just repairs. 

We want to be the only name that comes to your mind when you need any roofing services in Pennsylvania. We never compromise on the quality of roof repairs, replacements, or installations. 
To schedule your free roof inspection or to get a free roof estimate, call us today at (412) 353-5660.