What Is The Difference Between Architectural Shingles And Regular Shingles?

Choosing the suitable roofing material is a big decision for any homeowner, especially in areas with harsh climates like Pittsburgh, PA. Your roof isn't just there to keep rain out, it's a major part of your home's curb appeal, energy efficiency, and overall value.  With so many options on the market, it can be tough to know where to start.

This blog post will cover the main differences between two popular choices: architectural shingles and regular shingles. We'll arm you with the knowledge you need to make the best decision for your Pittsburgh home. 

If you’re looking to start a roofing project, click here for a ballpark estimate for your roof replacement.

Architectural Shingles vs. Regular Shingles

To better understand both architectural and regular shingles, let's quickly compare them across key factors.

#1 Composition

👉 Architectural shingles: These shingles are made with a heavier base mat and multiple layers of asphalt, giving them a contoured appearance that mimics the look of traditional wood shakes or slate. They are also popular as laminate or dimensional shingles.

👉 Regular Shingles: When we talk about "regular shingles," we're generally referring to 3-tab shingles. These are the most traditional type of asphalt shingle, known for their flat profile and uniform appearance. Each shingle has three tabs with cutouts, creating a distinct pattern across the roof.  

#2 Visual Comparison

👉 Architectural Shingles: This shingle option offers a more visually appealing, textured look with shadow lines that add depth and dimension to your roof. This can significantly improve the appearance of your home and potentially increase its value. 

👉 Regular Shingles: 3-Tab shingles have a flat, uniform appearance. While they come in various colors, they lack the visual interest and architectural detail of dimensional shingles.

#3 Durability And Lifespan

👉 Architectural Shingles: These shingles have a better design and a longer lifespan when compared to regular shingles. Architectural shingles generally last 20 to 30 years. They can easily withstand Pittsburgh's weather conditions, including snow, hail, and high winds.

👉 Regular Shingles: These shingles generally last 15 to 20 years. They are more susceptible to damage from wind uplift, cracking, and curling, potentially requiring earlier replacement and increasing long-term costs.

#4 Cost Analysis

👉 Architectural Shingles: They have a higher upfront cost per square foot compared to regular shingles. Architectural shingles can cost you anywhere between $3 and $10 per square foot.

👉 Regular Shingles:  These shingles are more budget-friendly at the time of installment. Expect to pay between $2 and $8 per square foot for regular shingles installation. 

#5 Installation Considerations

👉 Architectural Shingles: These may require more specialized installation due to their weight and layered design. 

👉 Regular Shingles: 3-Tab shingles are generally easier and faster to install, which can reduce labor costs.

What Are The Pros Of Architectural Shingles?

We will quickly go over why architectural shingles are more popular than 3-tab shingles:

1. They Last Longer

These shingles can protect your home for 20 to 30 years. That's about 10 years longer than regular roof shingles.

2. They're Stronger

Because they're made with extra layers, these shingles can take more of a beating from hail, falling branches, and everyday wear.

3. They Look Nice

These shingles have more depth to them because of their embedded shadow lines. They can make your roof look fancier, adding to your home’s overall appeal.

4. They Can Resist High Wind Speeds 

When the wind starts howling, these shingles hang on tight. Some options can handle winds up to 120 mph. 

What Are The Cons Of Architectural Shingles?

Now that you know the pros, it is important to have an idea of the potential challenges that homeowners commonly face with architectural shingles:

1. They Have A Higher Initial cost

You'll need to dig deeper into your wallet upfront. These shingles cost about 20% to 40% more than regular ones. However, the cost is worth investing in for their dimensional look and durability.

2. They're Heavy

These shingles weigh more, which might be a problem for some older houses or weaker roofs. Consult a professional to make sure your building’s structure can handle the weight of architectural shingles.

What Are The Pros Of Regular Shingles?

Here is an overview of the pros of regular shingles so you get an idea of if they are suitable for your home:

1. They Are Affordable

3-Tab shingles have a lower price than architectural shingles. They are great for projects with limited budgets. 

2. They Are Easy To Install

These shingles are simpler to install. Roofers can put them on quicker, which usually means you pay less for the work.

3. Easy to Find

You can get these shingles just about anywhere, so you won't have to look far or wait very long. However, you might not find as many styles and colors compared to architectural shingles.

What Are the Cons Of Regular Shingles?

It is also important to know the challenges that you might face with regular or 3-tab shingles:

1. They Have A Shorter Lifespan

Regular shingles usually start showing signs of wear after 15 to 20 years. That means you will likely need to replace your roof sooner than with other types.

2. They Have A Simple And Plain Look

These shingles are kind of flat and basic-looking. They don't have a dimensional appearance like architectural shingles, which some homeowners find less attractive. But they might suit your building if you are OK with a simple look.

3. Can Get Damaged Easier

When bad weather hits, these shingles might not hold up as well. They can get knocked loose by strong winds or cracked by hail more easily. However, if you live in an area with mild weather conditions, regular shingles may be a fine choice. 

Also Read: Top 5 Alternatives To 3-Tab Roof Shingles!

Choosing the Right Shingles for Your Pittsburgh Home

The best shingles for your home depend on your specific needs and priorities. Here are some factors to consider:

👉 Your Budget: Determine how much you're willing to invest upfront and consider the long-term costs of each option.

👉 Your Home's Style: Choose a shingle style that complements the architectural design of your home.

👉 Pittsburgh's Climate: Architectural shingles are better equipped to handle the Pittsburgh snow and storms without showing early signs of damage. 

👉 Desired Lifespan: If you plan to stay in your home for a long time, the longevity of architectural shingles might be the better investment.

Also Read: Best Roofing Shingles Of 2024 (& Top Manufactures)

Call McClellands Contracting and Roofing For Shingle Roofing Services in Pittsburgh, PA

We understand that choosing the right roofing material can be overwhelming. At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, we're committed to helping Pittsburgh homeowners make informed decisions about their roofs.

Our team of experienced roofing professionals can provide personalized guidance based on your home's unique needs and your budget. We'll walk you through the pros and cons of each option, answer your questions, and provide a free, no-obligation estimate.

Contact us today at (412) 353-5660 to schedule a consultation! We're proud to serve the local community and are dedicated to providing top-quality shingle roofing services in Pittsburgh, PA, and the surrounding areas.