Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Get In Touch
(412) 353-5660

The Top 5 Alternatives To 3-Tab Roof Shingles!

Posted on : September 19, 2023

The Top 5 Alternatives To 3-Tab Roof Shingles!

While 3-tab asphalt shingles have been a popular choice for homeowners for a long time, newer technology has been able to provide advanced alternatives that offer more durability, style, and boosted value for your investment.

In this blog post, I'll be your guide to explaining some of the top-notch alternatives to 3-tab roofing shingles. As a seasoned industry professional, I've seen trends come and go, and these five alternatives have proven themselves as game-changers in the roofing industry.

However, before we explore the alternatives to classic 3-tab asphalt shingles, let’s try to understand better what made this roofing material so popular in the first place. 

What Are 3-Tab Shingles? 

The 3-tab asphalt shingles were once the go-to roofing material, adorning roofs across the nation with their simple yet functional design. These shingles consist of a single flat layer of asphalt with three distinct tabs that are approximately equal in size, hence the name. Despite their traditional and straightforward appearance, they have served as a staple roofing choice for decades.

3-Tab Shingles

One of the primary draws of 3-tab shingles is their affordable cost and decent lifespan. 3-Tab shingles are a standard roofing material that can last around 15 to 20 years, depending on the climate and other environmental factors.

However, with changes in weather and the advancements in the roofing industry, a need for roofing materials that come with enhanced weather resistance, durability, and style, grew. Homeowners were also looking for options that required less maintenance. 

If you’re a homeowner who’s deciding to replace their 3-tab shingle roof, we’ve provided some of the newer options out there that can protect your home better than the classic option. You can also read our best roof shingles guide to understand what is hot in the market.

5 Best Substitutes for 3-Tab Roof Shingles

From material composition to shape and thickness, these new roofing materials are quite different than the classic 3-tab shingles.

#1 Architectural Asphalt Shingles

When it comes to roofing, architectural roof shingles are the modern-day marvels that defy conventional roofing expectations. Unlike their plain 3-tab counterparts, architectural shingles boast a multi-dimensional, textured appearance. This unique profile not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of your roof but also provides superior protection against the elements.

Architectural Shingle Features

👉 Enhanced Aesthetics: Architectural asphalt shingles come in a variety of shapes, designs, and colors, including ones that make them appear as slate or wood shingles.

👉 Enhanced Weather Resistance: With a thicker composition, architectural shingles are more robust and better equipped to withstand harsh weather conditions. Architectural shingles from renowned manufacturers can last for at least 30 years. 

👉 Durability: Unlike 3-tab shingles, architectural shingles often come with extended warranties, with a coverage of at least 30 years.

👉 Improved Resale Value: Upgrading your roofing material can significantly boost your home's resale value, and architectural shingles make a lasting impression.

I've personally witnessed the transformation that architectural roof shingles can bring to a home. Whether you're aiming for a classic or contemporary look, these shingles offer a versatile solution that elevates your home's curb appeal.

#2 Designer Roof Shingles

Designer Roof Shingles

Also known as premium and luxury roof shingles, designer shingles are the highest-quality asphalt-based shingles. They are multi-layered shingles reinforced with fiberglass or rubber. If you're looking to make a style statement with your roof without breaking the bank, this is the choice to consider.

Reasons to Choose Designer Roof Shingles

👉 Distinct Aesthetics: These shingles elevate the aesthetics of your home to a whole new level, closely resembling the classic look of cedar shakes or slate tiles. The authentic textures and patterns create a luxurious appeal!

👉 Durable and Low Maintenance: Despite their lavish appearance, premium shingles can last for around 40 to 50 years, providing a long-lasting roofing solution with minimal upkeep requirements. That’s much longer than a rapidly aging 3-tab shingle.

👉 Environmentally Friendly Options: Many designer shingles are made from recycled materials, aligning with the preferences of eco-conscious homeowners.

👉 Resistant to Harsh Elements: Luxury shingles are often designed to resist damage from severe weather conditions, ensuring a longer lifespan.

From Mediterranean to Tudor-style homes, designer asphalt shingles seamlessly blend luxury and resilience, presenting an ideal choice for those seeking an upscale roofing option.

#3 Composite Roofing Shingles

Composite Roofing Shingles

Composite roof shingles are a fusion of modern technology and traditional aesthetics. These shingles combine various synthetic and natural materials to create a durable, lightweight, and visually appealing roofing solution.

The Advantages of Composite Roofing Shingles

👉 Versatility in Design: Composite shingles come in a wide array of designs, mimicking the appearance of natural materials such as wood, slate, or even clay tiles.

👉 Weather Resistance: Like other alternatives, composite roofing shingles are also engineered to withstand harsh weather conditions, ensuring your roof remains intact and functional for years.

👉 Cost-Effective: Composite shingles offer a cost-effective alternative to natural and luxurious materials, providing a similar look and performance at half the cost and maintenance needs.

In my years of experience, composite roof shingles have emerged as a go-to option for homeowners seeking a balance between cost, durability, and aesthetic appeal.

Next on the list are metal roofing options. Metal roofs are eco-friendly, incredibly durable, and can be custom made. Plus, with their added benefits of energy efficiency and storm resistance, they’ve quickly become a safer choice for many homeowners. 

Read our blog post on the topic of metal roofs vs. shingles to better understand the comparison.

#4 Metal Roofing Panels

Metal Roofing Panels

Metal roofing panels have swiftly become one of the most sought-after alternatives to 3-tab roof shingles. Contrary to popular belief, metal panels are no longer reserved for industrial or commercial buildings. They've seamlessly transitioned into the residential sector, captivating homeowners with their charm and resilience.

Reasons to Embrace Metal Panels

👉 Modern and Minimalist Aesthetics: Popular panel profiles like standing seam and R-panels, offer a sleek appearance best suited for modern and minimalist architecture. 

👉 Durability Beyond Compare: Metal roofs are built to last 50 years and beyond, often surpassing the lifespan of asphalt roofs by several decades.

👉 Low Maintenance: With their resistance to rot, mildew, and fire, metal roofs require minimal upkeep, saving you a lot of time and money.

From modern homes to rustic cabins, metal roofing panels offer an eco-friendly and contemporary touch. I've witnessed the rise of metal roofs in the residential sector and their transformation into a symbol of progress and modernity.

#5 Metal Roofing Shingles

Metal Roofing Shingles

These are metal roofs that look like shingles, tiles, or shakes. This is a perfect option for those seeking the durability and energy efficiency of metal, but the look of wood, slate, or tile.

Why Should You Choose Metal Shingles?

👉 Customization: You can choose or customize metal roofing shingles to mimic the look of other roofing materials. With this roofing material, you can combine the aesthetics of wood shakes, slate, or clay tiles with the durability and longevity only metal can offer.

👉 Beauty of a Lifetime: While plain metal panels can develop visible scratches and dents over time, metal shingles have a designer appearance where these cosmetic issues are not visible to the naked eye.

👉 Low-Maintenance: You don’t need to prime and paint metal shingles as they are factory-finished products. But if you want to change your roof’s color, it’s possible to do so with the right kind of materials, techniques, and professionals. 

Explore the top 3 metal roof shingles chosen by our experts!

If you are open to increasing your budget a little, you can choose this highly cost-effective alternative to a 3-tab shingle roof. Its initial cost is higher than other materials, but it will pay off well over the years in terms of lower utility bills, minimal maintenance, and repairs with literally no need for replacement.

From the timeless elegance of architectural asphalt shingles to the sleek modern look of metal roofing panels, these alternatives to 3-tab shingles represent a revolution in roofing solutions.

Selecting the Right Roofing Material 

As an industry expert, I attest to the transformative power these roofing options bring to homes. Whether you prioritize aesthetics, durability, or sustainability, there's an option for you in this exciting array of roofing alternatives. Embrace the change, elevate your roof, and let your home stand as a testament to style and resilience.

Here are some tips on making the right choice:

1. Understand Your Priorities

Before making a decision, clearly define what matters most to you. Is it a particular style, the installation cost, or long-term value? Understanding your priorities will help you choose the roofing option that aligns with your values.

2. Consider Your Budget

Each roofing option comes with its own price tag, and 3-tab shingles are the cheapest. Evaluate your budget and choose an option that not only fits your financial capabilities, but also provides multiple benefits and long-term value.

3. Do Extensive Research

Dive into comprehensive research about each roofing alternative. Understand their pros, and cons, and how they perform in various conditions. This knowledge will empower you to make a wise choice.

4. Factor in Your Home's Aesthetics

Your roof is a significant part of your home's exterior. Consider the overall aesthetics of your house and select a roofing option that complements the style and architecture.

5. Consult a Professional Roofer

If you're ready to take the next step, consult a trusted roofing expert in your area for personalized guidance. At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, we’re here to help you select the best roofing material in Pennsylvania!

Schedule a Free Consultation For A Residential Roof Replacement in Pennsylvania

Ready to transform your home and boost its curb appeal with a brand-new roof? Our team at McClellands Contracting and Roofing is here to make this process as seamless and enjoyable as we can for you. Schedule a free consultation with one of our experts, explore your roofing possibilities, and learn more about our shingle roofing services in Pennsylvania. Let's craft a roof that not only protects, but also impresses!

Schedule A Consultation

Footer Form

By submitting, you allow McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC to contact you by phone, email, or text for more information. You can opt-out at any time. We will never share your personal information with third parties. Standard message/data rates may apply, and your consent is not tied to making a purchase.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Instant Quote Icon


Get a quote for your roof in under a minute!