Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Get In Touch
(412) 353-5660

Are Aluminum Gutters Really The Best or Are They Just Over Hyped? Busting Common Myths!

Posted on : July 25, 2023

Are Aluminum Gutters Really The Best or Are They Just Over Hyped? Busting Common Myths!

Among the various options available, aluminum gutters have garnered attention for their unique benefits. But are these gutters genuinely as good as they say, or are they just overhyped?

As an expert in the field, I’m here to clarify the confusion around aluminum gutters and help you understand if this gutter material is a good fit for your home. Let's dig deeper and explore the ins and outs of aluminum roof gutters to see if they live up to the expectations.

Why Are Aluminum Gutters So Popular?

Aluminum downspouts and gutters have gained immense popularity in recent years and for good reason. These lightweight, durable, and corrosion-resistant gutters have won the hearts of homeowners and contractors alike. But is their popularity justified? Let's find out!

Myth 1 - Aluminum Rain Gutters Are Weaker Than Steel Gutters

Some people believe that because aluminum is lightweight, it must be weak and easily damaged. However, that's far from the truth. While aluminum gutters are indeed lightweight, they are surprisingly naturally sturdy and can withstand heavy rainfall and snow without bending or breaking.

Myth 2 - Aluminum Downspouts And Gutters Are Expensive

It's a common misconception that aluminum drainage gutters are expensive. In reality, these gutters have a moderate price range compared to other gutter materials like stainless steel, copper, and zinc. Additionally, their corrosion-resistant nature and low maintenance requirements make them a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Myth 3 - Aluminum Roof Gutters Are Prone To Leaks

Critics argue that the lightweight quality of aluminum makes these gutters less reliable at forming a tight seal, leading to water leakage and potential damage. But the fact is, gutters tend to leak at the seams, which can be mitigated by using seamless gutters. So when installed correctly, and adequately maintained, aluminum seamless gutters are just as effective at preventing leaks as any other sturdy gutter system with no seams or sections.

Myth 4 - Aluminum Gutters Attract Lightning

One popularly believed myth surrounding metal gutters includes that they attract lightning and pose a safety risk to homes. This belief likely arises from aluminum being a good conductor of electricity. However, it's essential to understand that lightning is attracted to the highest point, and the presence of aluminum, or any other metal for that matter, does not increase the chances of a lightning strike. Properly grounded aluminum roofs and gutters are as safe as any other exterior material during a thunderstorm.

Myth 5 - Aluminum Downspouts And Gutters Only Have A Few Color Options

Some people believe that aluminum rain gutters offer limited options when it comes to styles and colors. They may assume that choosing aluminum means sacrificing aesthetic choices and settling for their natural silvery white shade. In reality, these gutters come in a wide range of styles, sizes, and colors, offering homeowners ample customization opportunities to complement their house's architectural design and personal preferences.

Now that we’ve debunked some common myths surrounding aluminum gutters, let’s explore the pros and cons of this gutter material.

Are Aluminum Gutters Really Good? Exploring The Benefits

Aluminum Gutters

Aluminum downspouts and gutters have plenty of advantages over other materials like vinyl.

Lightweight And Easy To Handle

One of the significant advantages of aluminum drainage gutters is their lightweight nature. This makes them a breeze to transport, handle, and install. You won't need to hire a whole team of heavy lifters, just a seasoned expert.

Excellent Color Retention

Aluminum roof gutters come with factory-applied finishes that keep their vibrant colors intact over the years. So, whether you choose classic white or a bold finish, your gutters will stay looking new for years to come. Plus, you can paint them too!


Worried about rust ruining your gutters? Aluminum is a champion when it comes to fighting corrosion. Rain or shine, your gutters will remain in good shape, providing reliable protection for your home. Plus, aluminum is resistant to salty weather conditions, such as the coast or saltwater lakes. 


Home improvement projects can get pricey, but here's some good news – aluminum gutters won't break the bank! Compared to premium materials like copper, aluminum downspouts and gutters offer fantastic value for their price without compromising quality.

Low Maintenance Requirements

Life can get busy, and gutters shouldn't add to your to-do list. Luckily, aluminum rain gutters are low maintenance. The occasional cleaning and inspection are all they need to stay in excellent condition.

Long Lifespan

With proper installation and care, aluminum seamless gutters can be your home's faithful protector for almost two decades!

Common Concerns With Aluminum Gutters And Downspouts

With these astonishing benefits, there are also some downsides that you should know about.

Possibility Of Dents

While aluminum downspouts and gutters are durable, they can be susceptible to dents when faced with heavy impacts like falling branches, flying objects, and hail stones bigger than an inch in diameter. 

Thermal Expansion And Contraction

These gutters expand and contract when exposed to extreme temperatures for long periods of time. This characteristic is common among metals and should be taken into account during installation. 

But is this gutter material better than steel and vinyl? Let’s find out.

Aluminum vs. Steel Gutters

When comparing aluminum and steel gutters, both materials have their strengths and weaknesses. Steel gutters are known for their exceptional strength and durability, making them suitable for areas with harsh weather conditions and heavy impacts. However, steel is prone to rust, so it needs to be coated with a layer of zinc or aluminum to resist corrosion.

On the other hand, aluminum is a lighter metal and boasts excellent resistance to rust, making it a preferred choice for most residential and commercial applications. Additionally, aluminum drainage gutters are more cost-effective, making them a sturdy option that costs less than stainless steel, copper, and zinc.

Aluminum vs. Vinyl Gutters

Vinyl gutters are very affordable, easy to handle, and are often used in areas with pleasant climates and low rainfall. However, vinyl gutters can become brittle or crack over time in extreme weather conditions. So if you are seeking a low-cost option with basic functionality, vinyl gutters may be a good option. However, if you prioritize durability and longevity, you’ll find aluminum to be a more reliable gutter material.

Along with the pros and cons, homeowners should also learn about the cost of installing aluminum metal gutters.

How Much Do Aluminum Gutters Cost?

Aluminum gutter installation costs between $8 to $15 per linear foot, and aluminum downspouts range from $12 to $30 per foot. However, your final cost depends on various factors, such as the design and thickness of the materials.

If you are looking to replace your rain gutters in Pittsburgh, PA, we can help you select the right material and style!

Get a Free Consultation And Estimate On Gutter Replacement In Pittsburgh

Do you feel your old rain gutters can’t hold up against the force of Mother Nature? We've got you covered! At McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC, our friendly experts are here to upgrade your home’s exterior with the perfect gutter system. Our team will offer personalized recommendations that suit your style and budget. 

If you need gutter replacement services in Pittsburgh, PA, call us at (412) 353-5660. We’ll be happy to help you with a free consultation and estimate on your gutter installation project. 

Let's work together to give your home the care it deserves. Embrace worry-free rainy days and ensure your house remains dry and cozy all year round.

Schedule A Consultation

Footer Form

By submitting, you allow McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC to contact you by phone, email, or text for more information. You can opt-out at any time. We will never share your personal information with third parties. Standard message/data rates may apply, and your consent is not tied to making a purchase.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Instant Quote Icon


Get a quote for your roof in under a minute!