Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Get In Touch
(412) 353-5660

Need A Gutter Replacement? Read This Guide For The Best Results!

Posted on : February 29, 2024

Need A Gutter Replacement? Read This Guide For The Best Results!

Are your rain gutters old or damaged? Do you frequently encounter issues like leaks, sagging, or water overflowing during rainstorms? If so, it may be time for a gutter replacement. Investing in new gutters is an essential way to safeguard your home from water damage and prevent expensive damage.

In this guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about replacing rain gutters, from the costs associated with replacement and different gutter styles, to whether or not you should choose a DIY, or professional installation.

Signs That You Need Gutter Replacement

Inspecting rain gutters is necessary to identify signs of damage and determine if a replacement is required. Here are some common indications that it's time for new rain gutters:

Visible Damage

holes, cracks, or rust spots on gutters

Multiple holes, cracks, or rust spots on your gutters are clear signs of damage that require immediate attention. Additionally, missing nails or screws can compromise the stability of the gutter system.

Water Overflow

Water Overflow

If you notice water running over the side of the gutters and down the siding, it indicates that your gutters are not effectively channeling water away from your home. This can lead to water damage to your foundation and exterior walls.

Sagging or Separation

Gutter troughs that sag or pull away from the roofline are unable to function properly. This may be due to deteriorating fascia boards or weakened fasteners. 

Exterior Damage

Exterior Damage

Peeling or chipping paint on your home's exterior, particularly near the gutters, can be a sign of water intrusion caused by leaky gutters.

Basement Leaks

If water leaks into your basement during rainstorms, or you find mold or algae in the basement, it may be a result of faulty gutters or downspouts, which causes excess water to reach the basement.

If you catch any of these signs, it means there’s a need to replace the damaged roof gutters or downspouts on your home. Let’s take a look at how much this replacement may cost.

Gutter Replacement Costs

The total cost of gutter replacement depends on various factors, including the material used, the linear footage needed, and the extent of damage. Here's a breakdown of the cost:

Material Choice

The material you choose for your new gutters will significantly impact the overall cost. While vinyl and steel gutters are popular, they are not very durable or appealing. Aluminum gutters are corrosion-resistant and cost-effective, with installation costs averaging around $3,000. Copper gutters, known for their decades-long durability and luxurious appeal, can cost $18 to $30 per linear foot.

Linear Footage

The length of your gutter system plays a significant role in determining the overall cost of your replacement. Replacing gutters and fascia boards typically costs between $6 to $20 per linear foot.

Additional Repairs

If your fascia boards or soffits are damaged, they will need to be replaced along with the gutters. The extent of these repairs will impact the total cost of the project.

To get an accurate estimate of the cost, you will need to consult a good gutter contractor in your area. The professionals will be able to assess the severity of damage and provide a detailed estimate based on your budget and style requirements. 

While replacing gutters yourself can save you money initially, you must evaluate the long-term costs, risks, and challenges involved.

Let’s now compare DIY replacement to professional gutter replacements, so that you can get a better idea of the option that’s right for you.

DIY vs. Professional Gutter Replacement

Replacing gutters and downspouts is a complex task that requires specialized knowledge and equipment. If you are thinking about doing it yourself, let’s take a look at the pros and cons of it.

Benefits Of Replacing Rain Gutters Yourself

Replacing Rain Gutters Yourself

Initial Savings On Labor

One of the most appealing aspects of DIY projects is the ability to save money by cutting out the costs associated with labor. With gutter and downspout replacement, the labor cost is almost half of the total expense since you’re the only one working on it and not a team of people.

Control Over The Installation Process

DIY enthusiasts often enjoy the autonomy that comes with tackling home improvement projects. When replacing gutters yourself, you have complete control over every aspect of the job and can keep things according to your schedule and standards.

Drawbacks Of DIY Replacement

Lack Of Expertise And Experience

Working with rain gutters and downspouts requires specific skills and knowledge to ensure optimum functionality and durability. Without prior experience or training, DIYers may overlook crucial steps or make errors that compromise the effectiveness of the system.

Increased Risk Of Improper Installation

Faulty gutter installation can lead to a host of issues, including moisture damage to your siding, home's foundation, or landscaping. Unskilled installations are more prone to mistakes such as inadequate slope, improper attachment, or insufficient sealing, which can result in leaks, clogs, or even structural damage over time.

Limited Access To Professional Tools And Equipment

Gutter and downspout installers have access to specialized tools and equipment designed to simplify the replacement process and achieve precise results. As a homeowner, you may not have these tools readily available, leading to challenges in executing the project efficiently and accurately.

Potential For Additional Expenses Due To Mistakes Or Damage

If you are not handy with this type of work, it increases the risk of error. If mistakes are made during the replacement process, such as damaging existing structures or improperly connecting sections, you may incur additional expenses to fix the issues and repair any resulting damage.

Advantages Of Professional Gutter Replacement

Expertise And Experience In Gutter Installation

Gutter professionals undergo training and have extensive experience in their field. They possess the knowledge and skills necessary to assess your home's specific needs, recommend appropriate materials, and execute the installation with safety and accuracy.

Access To Professional Tools And Equipment

Well established gutter contractors invest in high-quality tools and equipment designed specifically for gutter installation, which ensures successful results and minimizes the likelihood of errors or complications.

Efficient And Prompt Installation

Reliable local gutter contractors focus on working efficiently and methodically, completing the installation in a fraction of the time it might take for a homeowner or a handyman to tackle the project. Their experience can also minimize disruptions to your daily routine and ensure prompt completion of the work.

Assurance Of Quality Workmanship

When you hire a reputable gutter replacement company, you can trust that the work will be done to the highest standards of quality and professionalism. From precise measurements and proper alignment to secure attachment and thorough testing, professionals prioritize craftsmanship and attention to detail to deliver a durable and reliable gutter system.

Warranties And Guarantees On The Installation

Some gutter contractors offer workmanship guarantees and material warranties. These documents deliver satisfaction to homeowners as they can rely on the fact that if any issues arise post-installation, the company will fix them.

Concerns About Professional Gutter Services

Higher Upfront Cost Compared To DIY Projects

While professional services for gutter and downspout replacement offer numerous benefits, they may seem expensive to those on tight budgets. This cost encompasses labor expenses, materials, and any additional services or warranties provided by the installation company. However, it's essential to consider this investment in the context of long-term value.

Clearly, the benefits of professional installation outweigh the initial savings. Professional gutter installers have all the skills and knowledge to properly install durable gutters, minimizing the risk of future issues.

Hiring A Good Gutter Replacement Contractor

Choosing the right company is crucial for the success of your project, so here are some tips to help you find a reputable and reliable contractor:

Research and Reviews

Research local contractors and read customer reviews to check the reputation and the quality of work of potential contractors. Look for companies with a record of successful gutter and downspout replacements.

Licensing and Insurance

Make sure your chosen gutter contractor is licensed and insured to protect your home and yourself from liability in case of accidents or damage during the installation process. This insurance should also cover accidental harm to the workers.

Warranties and Guarantees

Ask about the manufacturer's warranties and workmanship guarantees offered by the contractor. A reputable company stands behind its work and works with reputable manufacturers to provide assurances of quality and customer satisfaction.

After hiring a contractor, discuss schedules, costs, downpayment, and contract details, ensuring that everything is clarified before signing the papers. 

Finally, to understand what’s happening during the replacement process, we’ve provided some basic knowledge.

Understanding The Gutter Replacement Process

Here's a step-by-step guide to help you navigate the work that a professional will take on:

Step 1: Inspection and Assessment

Before starting the replacement process, the professionals will thoroughly inspect your existing gutters and assess the extent of the damage. This will help determine the scope of the replacement project and identify any additional repairs that may be required.

Step 2: Material & Color Selection

Choose the type of gutters and guards that best suit your needs and budget. Weigh in durability, maintenance requirements, aesthetic appeal, and other factors. Common gutter materials include vinyl, galvanized steel, aluminum, and copper. After choosing the material, explore the available gutter colors and pick a compatible one. As for gutter guards, the style and size will depend on the gutters installed. 

Step 3: Measurements and Ordering

Accurate measurements of your gutter system are crucial for ordering the correct materials. The contractor will measure the linear footage of your gutters and downspouts to ensure an exact fit.

Step 4: Removal of Old Gutters

The gutter professionals will carefully remove the old gutters without causing damage to your roof or fascia boards. They will take proper precautions to protect your home's exterior during the removal process.

Step 5: Installation of New Gutters

The rain gutters will be installed according to the manufacturer's guidelines. A good contractor will ensure proper alignment, secure fastening, and appropriate slope for efficient water flow. Consider the use of hidden hangers for a clean and smooth appearance.

Step 6: Downspout Installation

Next comes the installation of downspouts. The contractor will place downspouts at strategic locations to channel water away from your home's foundation effectively. Make sure the downspouts stay away from walkways and landscaping features.

Step 7: Testing and Inspection

After the installation, the gutter professionals will thoroughly test the new gutter system by running water through it and checking for leaks or overflow. This final inspection is necessary to assess the overall function of the gutter system.

By choosing durable materials and investing in a reliable local gutter company, you can make sure that your new gutter system works fine and stays sturdy for decades!

If you need a reliable contractor to install new gutters in Pittsburgh, PA, we’re here to help!

Rely On Pittsburgh’s Top Rated Contractor For Gutter Replacement Services!

At McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC, we do our best to protect the homes in our community with our expert services. For many years, we’ve been installing high-quality gutter systems that work exceptionally well during rain and wind storms. We work with the industry’s top manufacturers and offer additional protection with custom gutter guard options. If you need gutter replacement in Pittsburgh or the surrounding area, reach out to us to discuss the best options for your home. Call us at (412) 353-5660 to book a free consultation and talk to one of our gutter experts today!

Schedule A Consultation

Footer Form

By submitting, you allow McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC to contact you by phone, email, or text for more information. You can opt-out at any time. We will never share your personal information with third parties. Standard message/data rates may apply, and your consent is not tied to making a purchase.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Instant Quote Icon


Get a quote for your roof in under a minute!