Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Our offers 5% off on senior Veteran Discount

Get In Touch
(412) 353-5660

Kitchen Countertop Replacement Guide: All You Need To Know 

Posted on : December 22, 2023

​​Kitchen Countertop Replacement Guide: All You Need To Know 

A kitchen countertop is one of the most used surfaces in your home. Over time, it might show signs of wear or merely fail to keep up with the evolving times and trends. And that's where a kitchen countertop replacement comes in. Replacing an old countertop can breathe fresh life into your beloved kitchen. 

So, let's dive deep into this comprehensive guide on kitchen countertop replacement, making sure you are well-prepared when it's time to make that significant change to the heart of your home.

Reasons for Replacing a Kitchen Countertop 

Kitchen countertop replacement might seem like a complex task at first glance, but there are compelling reasons that justify the importance of the project:

1. Outdated or Damaged Countertops

Outdated countertops not only fail to add aesthetic value to your space but also become challenging to maintain over time. A classic example is tile countertops, where the old grout can be difficult to clean. When you’re dealing with damage like stubborn stains or visible etching on lighter-colored materials, it’s probably time to invest in a kitchen countertop replacement that aligns with modern trends. Plus, a new countertop means simpler and more efficient cleaning.

2. Desire for a New Look or Style

As your taste matures or decor style evolves, enhancing the kitchen's visual appeal through an updated countertop can be worthwhile. Whether it's approaching cleaner modern lines after rustic wooden countertops or opting for quartz against subtle laminate. After all, aesthetics play a significant role in the overall feel of your kitchen. Undoubtedly, changing kitchen countertops will create an inspiring space that you love spending time in. 

Should You Repair or Replace Your Kitchen Countertop?

"Should I repair my existing countertop or replace it entirely?" This is a rather frequent question homeowners ask when they encounter issues with their kitchen countertops. The decision to either repair or replace a kitchen countertop depends on several critical factors.

While the thought of breathing new life into your old countertop might sound appealing and potentially more cost-effective, sometimes opting for a full-scale replacement can turn out to be the more practical and aesthetically pleasing option. 

Factors Influencing Your Decision

Carefully weighing these factors will help you enhance the aesthetic value and functionality of your countertops:

1. Level of Damage: First, consider the level of damage your countertop has sustained over the years. Minor scratches and chips often require simple repairs while major cracks and stains may necessitate immediate replacement.

2. Material Longevity: Many older materials are prone to damage, which frequently leads to constant repairs. Modern materials, conversely, offer superior durability and require minimal maintenance, making them a preferred choice for replacing an outdated countertop.

3. Aesthetic Considerations: Is your current countertop design in sync with the rest of your decor? If you've been looking for an updated look or want to incorporate modern design trends into your space, replacing your dated countertop might be a good choice.

What to Consider Before Replacing Kitchen Countertops

Before stepping towards your brand-new countertops, it's essential to have a thought out strategy. Figuring out the process involves assessing your needs and preferences, setting an appropriate budget, and researching various countertop materials.

Assess Your Needs and Preferences

Before you can narrow down your kitchen countertop choices, take a moment to understand what you truly need from your countertops. Are you looking for a visually stunning centerpiece that requires careful maintenance? Or do you favor functionality and durability over aesthetic appeal?

Consider key factors including kitchen usage, design preferences, the time you're willing to invest in maintenance, as well as long-term value. Each kitchen is unique, reflecting the habits, tastes, and priorities of its users. 

Set a Budget

Kitchen renovations can be very expensive if not correctly managed. Therefore, establishing a practical budget acts as a safeguard against escalating costs. Always remember to account for unexpected expenses like installation costs or additional requirements such as backsplashes when estimating your total.

It's wise to keep some flexibility in your budget, and keep in mind that unexpected issues might arise during the process that could involve minor adjustments here and there.

Research Countertop Materials

By understanding your needs and financial boundaries, you can efficiently explore all the available choices and find the perfect countertop material for your kitchen.

1. Wood Countertops

Laminate Countertops

Wood countertops undoubtedly add warmth and an inviting charm to any kitchen. Butcher block is a popular wood countertop choice due to its affordability and resilience when appropriately maintained. However, wood counters require regular sealing treatments and possible refinishing over time due to normal wear and tear or scratches. 

2. Laminate Countertops

Laminate Countertops

What laminate countertops lack in luxury, they make up for with practicality and affordability. They are durable, low maintenance, and available in a vast array of designs which can mimic other materials like rare natural stone or wood. Their heat-resistance levels aren't as high compared to most other countertop materials, but with careful usage, laminate counters can last for several years.

3. Other Countertop Materials

There are numerous options if neither wood nor laminate fits your kitchen vision. Options like granite or engineered quartz offer unparalleled durability with a bonus touch of opulence. Stainless steel countertops bring the look of a professional restaurant into home kitchens and stand out with their superior resistance to heat and stains.

For environmentally conscious homeowners, recycled glass countertops strike the perfect balance between eco-friendliness and modern aesthetics; While concrete countertops provide industrial chic charm coupled with durability.

Ultimately, the decision on kitchen countertop material largely hinges upon harmonizing personal preferences like style inclination and functional demands, with budget feasibility. Armed with an understanding of different materials' pros and cons lets you take on the countertop replacement confidently.

Cost of Kitchen Countertop Replacement

When it comes to renovating your kitchen, replacing the countertop tends to be a significant and unavoidable expense. It plays a central role in enhancing the aesthetic appeal as well as functionality of your cooking space. The primary question that surfaces when you plan this particular part of your renovation project is: how much does it cost to install a countertop?

Although there's no simple answer because prices vary widely based on multiple factors, I'll do my best to break down the costs for you.

The cost to install kitchen countertops can range from as low as $35 per square foot for budget-friendly options like laminate, up to $200 or more for high end materials like natural stone or quartz. But remember, material cost isn't the only necessary expenditure you'll encounter during a countertop replacement.

Don’t forget installation costs which can hover anywhere between $150 and $250 per square foot depending on whether you decide on a DIY approach or hire professionals. Additional expenses may also arise from complex installations involving unique shapes or large sizes, requiring precise measurements and special equipment.

If budget is one of your concerns and you want to install kitchen countertops with less financial strain, consider less expensive countertops such as tile and butcher block. These options can cut down your total kitchen overhaul costs while still offering reasonable durability and style.

Moreover, different retailers might offer varying countertops installation cost that includes both material plus labor charges. To navigate this maze effectively:

  • Request quotes from multiple local retailers.
  • Compare prices not just based on upfront charges but also considering long-term pros or cons associated with each type.

To sum up, calculating an exact figure without knowing specifics about your dream countertop can be difficult based on the influencing factors, including choice of material and complexity of design, making personal research and consideration vital to this process.

Understanding the general factors affecting cost can provide a starting point as you embark on your countertop replacement project.

The Countertop Replacement Process

A well-organized countertop replacement process can be both an enjoyable and rewarding experience. Whether you choose to do it yourself or hire a professional, the steps are largely similar:

  • Removal of Old Countertops: This initial step involves meticulous uninstalling and removal of your current countertops without damaging any other kitchen elements.
  • Measurement and Cutting: The next stage requires measuring the new countertop's dimensions as per your kitchen's layout, followed by precise cutting.
  • Installation: Lastly comes the actual installation of your countertops, which may also involve sealing depending on the material you've chosen.

Having understood these basic stages, let's now delve deep into deciphering DIY vs. professional installation.

DIY vs. Professional Installation: A Comparative Analysis

These days, with easy access to online tutorials and tools for just about everything under the sun, attempting a DIY countertop replacement might seem tempting. But before taking the plunge, allow me to go over some pros and cons of both DIY and professional installation:

DIY Approach


  • Cost Savings: If budget constraints are looming large over your countertop replacement project, taking this on yourself can save substantial money on labor costs.
  • Creative Control: It also provides 100% creative control, allowing you to modify plans at will without additional charges.


  • Technical Challenges: Lack of skill or expertise can lead to errors during measurement or installation.
  • Time Consuming: If you don’t have a lot of extra time on your hands, remember that such projects often require more time than initially estimated due to unexpected obstacles.

Professional Installation


  • Quality Assurance: Professionals bring in a depth of knowledge and experience which guarantees quality assurance.
  • Efficiency: Given their experience, professionals are likely to complete the project much more quickly than an amateur would.


  • Costly: Naturally, you'll have to pay for their expertise and time.

It's crucial to evaluate all these factors before deciding on whether to strap on your tool belt or invest in professional kitchen countertop installation. Consider your budget, availability, and the complexity of countertops you're working with. 


Having reached the end of this comprehensive guide, I hope you now have a clearer understanding of kitchen countertop replacement. It is not just about aesthetics, it's an investment towards your home's comfort and functionality.

If you’ve been thinking about renovating your kitchen, McClellands Contracting and Roofing in Pittsburgh, PA, can help. We offer comprehensive kitchen remodeling services, including countertop replacement. Call us today at (412) 353-5660 to schedule your free consultation. 

Schedule A Consultation

Footer Form

By submitting, you allow McClellands Contracting and Roofing LLC to contact you by phone, email, or text for more information. You can opt-out at any time. We will never share your personal information with third parties. Standard message/data rates may apply, and your consent is not tied to making a purchase.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Instant Quote Icon


Get a quote for your roof in under a minute!