(412) 353-5660
When it comes to designing your bathroom, one important decision to make is whether to install shower glass doors or shower curtains. Both options have their own advantages and drawbacks, so it’s essential to compare them according to your preferences.
At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, we’re here to help you choose the best option. In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of shower curtains and glass doors to help you customize your dream bathroom.
Let’s begin with the curtains!
When To Use Shower Curtains
Large curtains have long been a popular choice for enclosing showers due to their affordability and versatility. However, you should only choose shower curtains if the following things are high on your priority list:
Affordability
Curtains are generally more budget-friendly compared to glass shower doors. These curtains have a wide price range, starting from around $15 and reaching up to $50. You may need to pay for the rest of the parts used in hanging or installation and some protective accessories, too.
Privacy
Shower curtains offer better privacy from afar compared to glass doors. They completely enclose the bathing area, which is good if you want to block visibility completely. This can be particularly important if you have a shared bathroom or prefer a more secluded showering experience.
Color and Design Options
With shower curtains, you have a lot of options to choose from. Shower curtains are available in a lot of fabrics and materials with distinct features and costs. The most common materials used for shower curtains include linen, polyester, PEVA (polyethylene vinyl acetate), and more. This allows you to customize your bathroom decor and change the look whenever you desire.
While curtains have their advantages, there are a few considerations to keep in mind when you are deciding between shower curtains and glass doors.
Drawbacks Of Using Shower Curtains
Here are some of the major concerns associated with shower curtains:
Maintenance
Shower curtains require regular cleaning to prevent mold, mildew, and soap scum buildup. If not maintained properly, these curtains can become breeding grounds for bacteria and pose health risks. It’s important to wash or replace shower curtains as needed to maintain cleanliness.
Durability
Compared to glass shower doors, shower curtains may not be as durable. Over time, they can wear out, tear, or develop mildew stains. This means you may need to replace the curtains time and again, especially if you choose lower quality or less expensive options.
Condensation and Water Leakage
Curtains may not provide the same level of water containment as glass doors. Water can easily escape through the gaps or cling to the curtain, leading to water accumulation on the bathroom floor. You’ll need an additional accessory, like a shower liner, to minimize this issue.
Security Issue
Shower curtains do not provide security, they can only block the view. Curtains don’t have a locking system, and you may not feel as secure while bathing, especially if you live alone or don’t want to shut bathroom doors due to humidity or tight space.
Advantages Of Glass Shower Doors
Glass shower doors became popular in the 1960s and saw a significant rise in demand in the last few decades due to advancements in safety and design. In 2024, frameless glass doors fall among the leading choices for shower upgrades.
Here are the advantages of using shower glass doors over curtains:
Comfort
Glass shower doors provide an unobstructed view of the shower, creating a sense of openness and spaciousness in the bathroom. This is especially good for people with smaller bathrooms, as glass doors can make the space feel larger and less cramped. This option is also best for people who may feel suffocated in small or enclosed spaces.
Design and Versatility
Glass shower doors have a lot of options when it comes to designs, styles, and finishes, allowing homeowners to customize their shower space to suit their personal taste and decor preferences. From clear to frosted or textured glass, there are choices to complement any aesthetic. Additionally, glass doors can be installed in various configurations, including sliding, hinged, or pivot doors, making them versatile for different bathroom layouts and sizes.
Lighting
Glass shower doors allow natural and artificial light to reach freely, brightening up the shower area and making it feel more comfortable. This can create a more refreshing shower experience.
Safety and Security
Glass shower doors are safer and more secure than shower curtains. Some glass shower doors come equipped with locking mechanisms, delivering extra security and privacy while showering. This feature is very useful in households with multiple occupants or shared bathrooms.
Advanced glass doors are also manufactured using sturdy materials, including tempered glass, which is much stronger and more resistant to breakage than regular glass. In the rare event of an incident, tempered glass will crack or shatter but remain intact, instead of breaking down into sharp shards, reducing the risk of injury. Additionally, many modern glass shower doors come with features like anti-slam mechanisms and sturdy hardware to prevent accidents and ensure user safety.
Lower Change of Leaking
Glass shower doors provide a cleaner showering experience compared to traditional curtains. With curtains, there’s a higher chance of water splashing out onto the bathroom floor, leading to potential slip hazards and water damage. Glass doors, on the other hand, create a sealed enclosure, minimizing water leakage and keeping the surrounding area dry. This not only reduces the need for frequent cleaning but also ensures a safer and more hygienic showering environment.
Increased Home Value
Glass shower doors can significantly increase the value of a home. Potential buyers often see them as a modern and luxurious feature, adding to the overall appeal of the bathroom. Additionally, they contribute to the aesthetic and contemporary design of the space, which can attract more buyers and result in a higher selling price for your property.
Concerns About Glass Shower Doors
While glass shower doors offer numerous benefits, there are a few concerns too:
Cost
Glass shower doors can be more expensive upfront compared to shower curtains. The average cost for installing glass shower doors is approximately $900, with a range from $500 to $1,300. This cost includes materials and labor. The cost depends on factors such as the type of glass, size, and design customization. However, the long-term durability and luxurious beauty of glass doors often justify the initial investment.
Installation Challenges
Installing glass shower doors can be more complex and labor intensive than hanging curtains. Proper installation requires precise measurements, leveling, and sealing to ensure a secure and watertight fit. Improper installation can lead to issues like leaks, misalignment, or damage to surrounding tiles or fixtures. Hiring a professional installer is generally necessary, adding to the overall cost.
How To Choose Between Shower Curtains and Glass Doors
When making a choice between glass shower doors and curtains, consider the following factors:
Budget
Determine how much you are willing to spend on your shower. Glass shower doors generally have a higher upfront cost compared to curtains, so consider your budget constraints.
Aesthetic Preferences
Think about the overall look and feel you want to achieve in your bathroom. Glass shower doors offer a modern look and feel, while curtains can provide a softer and more traditional look.
Maintenance
Consider your willingness to perform regular cleaning and maintenance tasks. Glass shower doors require periodic cleaning to avoid water spots and soap residue buildup, whereas curtains may need to be replaced more frequently due to mold and mildew growth.
Space Constraints
Keep in mind the size and layout of your bathroom. Shower glass doors can create a sense of openness and spaciousness, making them ideal for any size bathroom. However, curtains may be a better option if space is limited or you prefer the flexibility to push them aside when not in use.
Privacy and Security
Consider your privacy preferences and the needs of your household. Glass shower doors offer a more enclosed and secure showering experience, while curtains may provide more privacy, especially if the bathroom is shared among multiple occupants.
Long-Term Investment
Think about the resale value of your home. Compared to shower curtains, glass shower doors are generally considered a desirable feature that can enhance the appeal and value of your home. If you plan to sell your home in the future, investing in shower glass doors may be a worthwhile long-term investment.
Ultimately, the choice between glass shower doors and curtains depends on your individual preferences, budget, and practical considerations.
If you need more information or want to speak to an expert, we’re here to help!
Upgrade Your Shower & Bath Experience With Pittsburgh’s Best Bathroom Remodelers!
At McClellands Contracting and Roofing, we’re proud to be the most trusted experts for home interior and exterior renovations in Pittsburgh, PA. We have been transforming kitchens, bathrooms, and basements for years, and our customers love the results! If you want bathroom or shower upgrades in Pittsburgh or the surrounding area, don’t hesitate to reach out! Call us at (412) 353-5660 for a free consultation today.
